Does Kryptonite Exist?

You might have recently read online that a mining team in Serbia came across a rock with precisely the same chemical name as Kryptonite, the fictional rock from the Superman comics.  So did they find Kryptonite?  ‘Well of course not,’ you say.  ‘The thing doesn’t exist.’  But then this question arises: To what do you refer when you say of this object “Kryptonite,” that it does not exist? 

After all, I can point to it.  Well, perhaps not with a finger, but when I say the name “Kryptonite,” you know what I mean:  That there is something there that I am singling out; something to which I refer, and it is this thing, we are saying, that doesn’t exist.  But how can there be something there that doesn’t exist?  Does the name Kryptonite, have a referent? 

Here’s how a Meinongian might respond.

(1) We have intentional states (e.g. ‘fear’) only if there is some real object responsible for that intentional state (e.g. fear of a dog).

(2) We have intentional states about Kryptonite (e.g. we admire Kryptonite).

(3) No non-Kryptonite entity is responsible for the intentional state e.g. of my admiring Kryptonite.

(4) Therefore, there is a real entity Kryptonite.

Now to back-pedal a bit, I should say that the Meinogian will parse the “is” in that last proposition as “subsists” and not “exists”, but for now, that’s neither here nor there.  What’s important is that when we say the name Kryptonite, the Meinongian argues that it does refer to a real object and not something merely the figment of our imagination.

6 Responses to Does Kryptonite Exist?

  1. Jason Dollar says:

    Xav, great to see you using your years of education on something important! Just kidding. But I really have no idea what you are talking about. Well, kind of I guess. I like Superman.

    So did you know that Chuck has a new CD?? It is not as good as Bandolhoot, but it is really good. http://www.chuckhooten.com. Tell me what you think. Too bad he left Bandolhoot, we could have really propelled him forward in his “career.”

  2. Susan says:

    Xavier,
    this always messes with my head because the definition of ‘exist’ seems slippery depending on the philosopher.

  3. Keith says:

    Hey man, Ryan Nichols has a good article on Thomas Reid and Meinogianism. It’s titled “Reid on Fictional Objects and the Way of Ideas” [The Philosophical Quarterly, vol. 52, #209, Oct. 2002].

  4. Tahmid says:

    kryptonite might exist, i come across rocks in the north pole where i go for a vacation, it has crystals and it has an effect on me please reply.

  5. zsukar says:

    Jason Dollar,

    I am looking for a friend of mine, called Donnie Simms, an old friend of mine. He used to play in the Bandolhoot. Could you tell me how i can contact him?
    Thnaks

  6. zsukar says:

    can anyone tell me how I can contact Don Simms from Birmingham Alabama?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: